We’re trying to rent out our flat in Bangalore, and a week ago a Muslim family inquired about it. I mentioned this to a friend and it became clear that we would be ill-advised to rent to them. Seemed illogical, but I’m the air-head NRI, out of touch with ground reality, so I asked around.
Every single person I talked to advised me against renting to Muslims.
“Why take a chance?”
“They may be decent folk but some mama/chacha/cousin will come from Karachi and they won’t even know what he’s up to”
“When they find any hanky panky they catch the homeowner first. You’ll be charged with harbouring a terrorist”
“You guys aren’t here, they’ll catch your family and put them in jail. Log mahino tak gaayab ho jaate hain (people disappear for months)”
“I’ve heard that no one will rent to Muslims, some people are even refusing to sell to them”
“How would you feel knowing a bomb was made in your beautiful new house?”
Imagine how the Muslim community must feel, denied accommodation (and God knows what else) on the sole basis of their religion. Is it any wonder they live in ghettos, embittered, feeling like second-class citizens? They’ve stood shoulder to shoulder with other Indians in the wake of the Mumbai terror attack. Yet we have trouble trusting them.
And what of me the “educated” intellectual? What am I to do? It’s true that the majority of terrorist incidents are Muslim-perpetrated. It’s true that the landlords are harassed when subversive activity takes place in a home. It’s very possible that in my absence my family will be targeted by law enforcement. I know theoretically it shouldn’t happen, but it does. If POTA comes back civil rights will be even more curtailed.
So I can stand by my liberal ideals and risk the comfort and dignity of the people I love. Or I can turn hypocrite and bigot - preaching tolerance, practicing discrimination.
I’m not sure what my decision will be in this case, but it’s unfair that this is my choice.